Why Auto Insurance Is So Expensive in the “High-Cost States” (2025)

State-by-State: what’s uniquely expensive (and what’s changing)

Rankings vary by source and driver profile. Use this section to explain the price you’re seeing and to pick the right savings lever.

Nevada (Las Vegas/Reno gravity)

• Why it’s high: urban congestion, higher-than-average fraud/litigation pressure, population growth → more miles and claims; regulators note repair-cost inflation and aggressive driving as active headwinds. doi.nv.gov
• What it means for you: city ZIPs (esp. Las Vegas/North Las Vegas) tend to price much higher than suburbs; night-time and weekend driving data in telematics programs can materially move the price.

Florida (reform in motion)

• Why it’s high: long-standing PIP/no-fault quirks, fraud/staged accidents/windshield litigation; storm losses; many uninsured drivers. Good news: 2024–2025 tort reforms are translating into average ~6.5% personal-auto rate cuts at the top insurer groups. Lawmakers continue to debate PIP repeal/at-fault shifts for 2026. insurancebusinessmag.com+3insuranceindustryblog.iii.org+3PropertyCasualty360+3
• What it means for you: shop again—2025 filings show cuts at multiple carriers; pair with telematics to stack the effect.

Michigan (PIP structure & the MCCA)

• Why it’s high: generous medical benefits under no-fault, plus the MCCA assessment that’s passed into premiums (still there, though the 2025–2026 fee trimmed to $82 for unlimited PIP and $23 for other PIP levels). Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association
• What it means for you: choosing a non-unlimited PIP level (after understanding medical trade-offs) + telematics can drop quotes dramatically; keep an eye on annual MCCA adjustments.

Louisiana (tort climate, with 2025 changes)

• Why it’s high: historically plaintiff-friendly tort environment and high BI severity; 2025 tort-reform bills aim to rebalance (details still shaking out). insuranceindustryblog.iii.org+1
• What it means for you: as reforms phase in, re-quote at renewal; small filing shifts can create big ZIP-level differences.

Missouri / Colorado (convective storms, hail, theft pockets)

• Why it’s high: hail and severe-storm losses make comp claims costly (MO’s 2025 insured losses approached $2B; CO is historically hail-heavy). Theft in certain metros also loads rates. dci.mo.gov+1
• What it means for you: comprehensive deductibles and secure garaging evidence help; compare comp-deductible scenarios (often $500 vs $1,000 is a clean trade).

California / New York / New Jersey (big metros + regulation)

• Why it’s high: dense traffic + pricey repairs; regulatory frameworks shape how fast insurers can adjust rates. In 2025, California policy debates signal ongoing market tension; nationwide, states are experimenting with different levers to cool premiums. CalMatters+1

One more structural factor across states: uninsured motorists—the national UM rate was 15.4% in 2023 (with sharp increases in places like Missouri and New Jersey), which raises UM/UIM costs for everyone. III

Next page: How to actually pay less (without getting under-insured) →

great-trip編集部

writer

Hello, I'm a new member of "great-trip" and I'm looking forward to meeting you! Welcome to "great-trip"! great-trip" is a website designed to introduce tourist attractions in Japan. This site will help you with your next trip by providing detailed information on various tourist attractions in Japan. The site provides easy-to-understand and friendly content so that even those new to planning a trip can find the information they are looking for with ease. great-trip" is operated with the hope of conveying the wonders of Japan's sightseeing spots to as many people as possible. We hope that visitors to our site will find travel enjoyable and appealing, and that we can help them find their next travel destination. As your travel plans progress, discover new aspects of Japan and create wonderful memories. Let's go on a great trip to Japan together! Discover your next travel destination with "great-trip". We look forward to seeing you soon!